How much should you spend on ads to grow profitably? Use a simple model: CAC, LTV, payback and ROAS. Below are formulas, input checklist and a realistic numeric example.
What we measure (and why)
- CAC — customer acquisition cost.
- LTV — gross margin value over the customer’s lifetime.
- Payback — months to break even.
- ROAS / tROAS — revenue (or margin) from ads divided by ad spend.
Core formulas
“CAC = Ad spend / New customers”
“LTV (subscription) ≈ ARPU × Gross margin × Avg lifetime (months)”
“LTV (transactional) ≈ AOV × Purchase frequency × Margin × Time horizon”
“LTV/CAC — target ≥ 3:1 (higher for aggressive growth)”
“Payback (months) ≈ CAC / (ARPU × Margin)”
“Break-even ROAS ≈ 1 / Margin”
Top-down vs bottom-up budgeting
- Top-down (from growth goal): need N customers → budget = N × target CAC.
- Bottom-up (from channel metrics): Clients = Clicks × CR(click→lead) × CR(lead→sale); then CAC = Spend / Clients.
Mini calculator: inputs
- CPC & CTR by channel (search, social, remarketing).
- CR click→lead and CR lead→sale.
- ARPU/AOV and gross margin.
- Time horizon: payback window (1–12 mo) and LTV window (12–24 mo).
- Target # of new customers or revenue/margin target.
Numeric example (B2B services)
Assume CPC = $1.2, CR click→lead = 3%, CR lead→sale = 20%.
- Clicks per customer: 1 / (0.03 × 0.2) ≈ 166.7.
- Ad cost: 166.7 × $1.2 ≈ $200 → expected paid CAC.
- ARPU = $150/mo, margin = 60% → monthly margin = $90.
- Payback: $200 / $90 ≈ 2.2 months.
- Avg lifetime 10 mo → LTV ≈ $150 × 0.6 × 10 = $900. LTV/CAC = 4.5 — strong.
Channel allocation
- Search (high intent): usually best CAC, limited volume.
- Social (demand gen): higher CAC, scalable reach.
- Remarketing: low CAC, limited ceiling.
- Branded search: cheapest — protect your brand demand.
- 70/20/10 rule: 70% proven, 20% scale, 10% tests.
Blended vs Paid CAC & attribution
- Paid CAC — ads only. Blended CAC — total marketing / customers (includes organic/brand).
- Track both: Paid for tactical decisions, Blended for management view.
- Attribution: last-click undervalues upper-funnel; maintain a summary view across models.
Hidden costs & budget leaks
- Creative production, LP split-tests, tooling (trackers/heatmaps).
- Learning phase and segment tests (don’t expect perfect CAC in week 1).
- Weak landing CR multiplies CAC — fix CR before scaling spend.
- Poor lead qualification — cheap leads without sales: tighten scoring & handoff.
Guardrails & targets
- LTV/CAC ≥ 3:1; 4–5:1 for faster growth.
- Payback: SaaS 3–6 mo; services aim for ≤ 3 mo if possible.
- tROAS: anchor to break-even (= 1/margin) and add safety premium.
Writing a simple media plan
- Pick a goal: N customers/mo or monthly margin target.
- Pull realistic CPC/CR per channel (history or benchmarks).
- Compute CAC by channel; add 10–20% test buffer.
- Budget = N × target CAC (or derive from tROAS).
- Milestones: weeks 1–2 (learning), 3–4 (stabilize), month 2 (scale).
Wrap-up
Keep it simple: estimate CAC bottom-up, validate against LTV and payback, reserve a test bucket, and enforce funnel discipline (landing CR, lead scoring, attribution). Then ad spend becomes a lever, not a cost.